Fox News settles Dominion defamation case for $787.5mon April 18, 2023 at 9:53 pm

- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -

“Lies have consequences,” says a lawyer for the voting firm about the network’s false election claims.

This video can not be played

To play this video you need to enable JavaScript in your browser.

Fox News has settled a defamation lawsuit from the voting machine company, Dominion, over its reporting of the 2020 presidential election.

In a last-minute settlement before trial, the network agreed to pay $787.5m (£644m) – about half the $1.6bn initially sought by Dominion.

Dominion argued its business was harmed by Fox spreading false claims the vote had been rigged against Donald Trump.

The deal spares Fox executives such as Rupert Murdoch from having to testify.

The judge in the case is not required to give his approval for the settlement.

In a statement, Fox said Tuesday’s settlement in one of the most anticipated defamation trials in recent US history reflected its “commitment to the highest journalistic standards”.

The Fox statement added that the network “acknowledges the court’s rulings finding certain claims about Dominion to be false”.

Dominion chief executive John Poulos told a press conference the deal included Fox “admitting to telling lies, causing enormous damage to my company”.

Justin Nelson, a Dominion attorney, told reporters that “the truth matters”.

“Lies have consequences,” he added. “Over two years ago a torrent of lies swept Dominion and election officials across America into an alternative universe of conspiracy theories, causing grievous harm to Dominion and the country.”

Mr Nelson added that for “democracy to endure”, Americans must “share a commitment to facts”.

Rupert and Lachlan Murdoch

Image source, Getty Images

Opening arguments in the case had been due to start on Tuesday afternoon.

The announcement of a settlement came after an unexplained delay of several hours once jury selection had finished, prompting speculation that talks were underway behind the scenes.

On Monday, Delaware Superior Court Judge Eric Davis announced that the start of the trial would be delayed by 24 hours.

Although he gave no reason, US media reported that it was to give both sides an opportunity to reach a settlement.

On Tuesday morning, however, both sides appeared to be digging in for a lengthy trial.

Attorneys for Fox had repeatedly objected to the $1.6bn in damages sought by Colorado-based Dominion, characterising the figure as massively inflated.

The “real cost” of the case, Fox said, would be the “cherished” rights to freedom of speech and of the press enshrined in the First Amendment of the US Constitution.

Dominion’s lawsuit argued that the conservative network had sullied the electronic voting company’s reputation by airing falsehoods about the 2020 vote being stolen from former President Trump.

The lawsuit claimed that the false claims were partly an effort to win over viewers angry by Fox’s decision to – correctly – call the crucial electoral state of Arizona in favour of Mr Trump’s then-challenger, Joe Biden.

Two of the Fox executives responsible for the Arizona decision lost their jobs two months later.

Legal findings released ahead of the trial suggested that a number of Fox executives and journalists privately questioned and dismissed conspiracy claims that the 2020 presidential election was stolen, but still put them on air.

Court documents show that Mr Murdoch referred to the claims about Dominion as “really crazy”, but failed to take any action.

In one series of text messages, top-rated host Tucker Carlson said some of the claims were “insane”. Another host, Sean Hannity, said privately he did not believe them “for one second”.

Fox has said the words were taken out of context.

Ahead of the trial, Judge Davis ruled that the claims against Dominion had already been proven false, emphasising that the falsehoods were “crystal clear”.

Had the trial gone on, jurors would have been tasked only with determining whether Fox News acted with “actual malice” by broadcasting claims it knew to be false.

Despite the mammoth pay-out, some legal experts believe the settlement was overall a positive outcome for the network.

Syracuse University professor and First Amendment expert Roy Gutterman said: “Looking down the line at a six-week trial, this was going to be gruelling for everyone involved and likely embarrassing for Fox.

“But a verdict against Fox could have been even costlier, and had serious implications on subsequent rulings on the actual malice standard and the First Amendment itself.”

Civil litigation attorney Michelle Simpson Tuegel told the BBC that the settlement “speaks to the massive threat Fox saw from this litigation”.

“The reputational harm of having executives, including chairman Rupert Murdoch, and hosts take the stand seems to have moved the parties towards a resolution,” Ms Tuegel added.

Fox still faces a second, similar defamation lawsuit from another election technology firm, Smartmatic, which is seeking $2.7bn.

Dominion still has legislation pending against two conservative news networks, OAN and Newsmax.

The company has also sued Trump allies such as Rudy Giuliani, Sidney Powell and Mike Lindell.

- Advertisement -

Discover

Sponsor

Latest

US midterms: How BBC’s voter profiles were shown hate and disinformation onlineon November 7, 2022 at 1:06 am

The BBC's Marianna Spring investigates what voters are being recommended online at a turbulent time for US politicsThe BBC's Marianna Spring investigates what voters...

Ukraine: Putin has already carried out war crimes – Boris Johnsonon March 2, 2022 at 1:44 pm

Russia's bombing of "innocent civilians" in Ukraine already amounts to war crimes, prime minister says.This video can not be playedTo play this video you...

Winter Olympics: Eve Muirhead on finally winning gold at fourth Gameson February 20, 2022 at 12:15 pm

The GB women's curling captain reacts to getting a gold medal at her fourth Winter Olympic Games.The GB women's curling captain, Eve Muirhead, has...

Fourth patient seemingly cured of HIVon July 27, 2022 at 2:13 pm

A man who has had HIV since the 1980s had a bone marrow transplant from a donor resistant to the virus.Image source, Getty ImagesA...

World Cup 2022: Jude Bellingham header gives England lead over Iranon November 21, 2022 at 1:54 pm

Watch as Jude Bellingham scores his first international goal to give England the lead against Iran in the Fifa World Cup in Qatar.Watch as...