Ashling Murphy: Man sentenced to life for Irish teacher’s murderon November 17, 2023 at 5:25 pm

The man convicted of murdering Irish schoolteacher Ashling Murphy has been handed a life sentence.

Jozef Puska, 33, from Lynally Grove in Mucklagh, County Offaly, was found guilty at a court in Dublin last week.

Puska stabbed the 23-year-old 11 times in the neck as she jogged on the banks of the Grand Canal near Tullamore, County Offaly, on 12 January 2022.

Ms Murphy’s death caused widespread shock, prompting vigils across Ireland and the UK.

Judge Tony Hunt said he could not hand down a whole life sentence but if he could it would be “richly deserved”.

Dressed in a grey suit with a white shirt and no tie, Puska made no comment or reaction when the sentence was handed down to him through a translator.

The court heard Puska and Ms Murphy, a talented folk musician, were not known to each other and had never met before the attack.

Puska, who is a Slovak national, had pleaded not guilty to her murder.

He has no criminal record here or in Slovakia and had never come to the attention of gardaí (Irish police) before the killing.

He claimed he was trying to help Ms Murphy after she had been attacked by another man, who went on to stab him too.

Before his arrest, Puska confessed to the killing after being admitted to St James’ Hospital in Dublin for treatment to stab wounds the day after Ms Murphy was killed, the court heard.

He initially told staff in the hospital he had been stabbed in a separate incident in Blanchardstown on the outskirts of Dublin

The judge said in the hours before his surgery, Puska was initially composed enough “to spin a detailed yarn” to healthcare staff.

Gardaí attended the hospital to investigate but were immediately suspicious and made a connection to Ms Murphy’s murder.

“Something was a bit off” with Puska, the judge said.

After his surgery, police officers from Tullamore attended the hospital and spoke with Puska about executing a warrant.

Puska then confessed to a Garda officer, claiming he did not mean to hurt Ms Murphy and killing her was the result of “panic”.

Gardaí said the confession took them by surprise as they had not attended the hospital to interview Puska.

He repeated his confession after being cautioned by the officers, but the interaction was not recorded.

However, a few days later Puska said he had no recollection of the incident.

His defence counsel said this was due to pain medication he was taking.

This claim was later disputed by a pain specialist during the trial.

During sentencing, Judge Hunt said the minor level of medication would “not cause amnesia for major events”.

The judge said Puska gave his confession “lucidly” and was “perfectly coherent” that afternoon.

He praised the Slovak translator who heard the confession, highlighting his “clarity and independence” when giving evidence and said it was fortunate he was present.

The court also heard that DNA evidence belonging to Puska was found under Ms Murphy’s fingernails.

One eyewitness said they had seen Mr Puska on top of Ms Murphy in a hedgerow with her legs kicking out underneath him.

When Puska saw the witness he shouted at her to go away, the court heard.

Ashling’s boyfriend Ryan Casey read a victim impact statement in court, taking long pauses to compose himself.

He described how he and Ashling had met an architect weeks before she died as they were planning to build a house together and get married. They also planned to spend sometime in Dubai before returning home and starting a family.

“I’d smile to myself thinking, I cant wait to marry that girl. I would’ve married her a long time ago and I wish I did but we didn’t get a chance to reach that part.”

“Every single plan I had for life is gone and cannot be brought back.

“I’ve lost everything; the pain of losing someone so important is indescribable,” he said.

He said that Puska was “insignificant, the lowest of the low, waste of life” who had no idea what he had done to the Murphy family.

Mr Casey said he had nightmares, he has become short tempered, and does not like looking at or eating with knives.

“I find myself hating myself for small moments of happiness, feeling guilty for feeling happy. Feeling lost in life with no direction and with no light at the end of the tunnel.”

He said the last time he saw Ashling they could not touch as he had been infected with Covid 19. He regrets that every day, he told the court.

“Ireland has officially lost its innocence that a crime of this magnitude can be done in daylight,” he said.

“Our country is heading down a very dangerous path and we will not be the the last family.”

Facing Puska, Mr Casey said: “May you be in hell a whole half hour before God even knows you’re dead.”

Ashling’s mother Kathleen wrote a victim impact statement that was read by a police officer in court.

She wrote: “My heart broke when I heard Ashing was murdered. My memory, motivation and drive for life is gone forever.

“I cant bear it. I am no longer able for big crowds or small talk.”

She told the court how she had asked Ashling to jog near their home the day she was murdered. Ashling refused saying she was an adult of 23 and told her mother she loved her.

Amy Murphy, Ashling’s older sister said the family still set the table for five people and that the house is “eerily quiet” without their youngest sister.

Speaking directly to Puska, Ms Murphy said: “Ashling’s last ten minutes on this earth must have felt like the longest ten minutes of her life.

“You stole her life, took her voice and robbed us of our family of five.”

Puska, currently separated from other inmates at Cloverhill Prison for his own safety, will now be moved to Dublin’s Mountjoy prison.

He is undergoing psychiatric supervision after attempting to take his own life during the trial.

Ms Murphy’s death sparked a new conversation about violence against women in Ireland and renewed pressure on the Irish government to tackle the issue.