Aspartame advice unchanged despite cancer questionon July 13, 2023 at 11:52 pm

- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -

The sweetener is found in a variety of foods, from diet drinks to chewing gum and some yoghurts.

Boy drinking cokeImage source, Getty Images

Advice on how much aspartame we can eat or drink is unchanged, despite the sweetener being classified as “possibly” causing cancer.

Two groups of experts at the World Health Organization have been reviewing thousands of scientific studies.

The “possibly carcinogenic” label often causes fear and confusion, but just means the evidence is unconvincing.

Most people consume less than the safe upper limits of aspartame, but the WHO recommends heavy consumers cut down.

Aspartame is found in diet and sugar-free versions of foods, as the chemical gives a taste 200 times sweeter than sugar for little calories.

Famous brands containing the sweetener include Diet Coke, Coke Zero, Pepsi Max and 7 Up Free, but aspartame is in around 6,000 products ranging from toothpaste and chewing gums to yoghurts and cough sweets.

Despite being so widespread, the chemical’s safety has been a source of controversy since it was introduced in the 1980s.

I asked Dr Francesco Branca, the director of the department of nutrition and food safety at the World Health Organisation (WHO), what was the healthier choice: sugar or sweetener?

He told me: “Faced with a decision of whether to take cola with sweeteners or one with sugar, I think there should be a third option, which is to drink water instead and to limit the consumption of sweetened products altogether.”

He said the reviews had “raised the flag” that aspartame may not be great for your health, but said you “shouldn’t have a concern” about an occasional diet drink or other product containing the sweetener, adding “the problem is for high consumers”.

The first body to assess the evidence was the WHO’s cancer experts – the International Agency for Research on Cancer.

IARC uses four possible classifications:

  • Group 1 – Carcinogenic (cancer causing) to humans
  • Group 2A – Probably carcinogenic to humans
  • Group 2B – Possibly carcinogenic to humans
  • Group 3- Not classifiable

It has moved aspartame into the “possibly carcinogenic” category alongside other substances such as aloe vera and lead. This decision largely centres on three studies suggesting a connection to a type of liver cancer.

However, the “possibly” refers only to the strength of scientific evidence. If the evidence was strong, then aspartame would be in a higher category.

Dr Mary Schubauer-Berigan, of the International Agency for Research on Cancer, said the “evidence was not of sufficiently high quality or convincing enough” and “this is really more a call to the research community” to study the sweetener more.

The cancer classifications frequently lead to misleading headlines. Alcohol and plutonium are in the same category (both are proven to cause cancer), but one is seriously more dangerous than the other.

So a separate body – the World Health Organization and the Food and Agriculture Organization Joint Expert Committee on Food Additives – has the job of working out safe doses.

It analysed the cancer risk as well as other issues such as heart disease and type 2 diabetes, but found “no sufficient reason” to alter the advice it has had since 1981.

So the safe limits remain at 40 milligrams per kilogram of your body weight, per day.

Graphic showing the maximum amount of aspartame that can be ingested daily before it becomes a cancer risk: Men can drink up to the equivalent of 17 cans of fizzy drink containing 200mg of aspartame; Women can drink up to the equivalent of 14.4 cans; a 10-year-old child can drink up to the equivalent of 6.4 cans.

These aren’t targets, they’re the upper safety limits. But as the advice is based on body weight, it is easier for children to get close to the limit.

Dr Branca said it was “not a good practice” to have a bottle of sweet fizzy drink on the table at family dinner time, as children risked being set up with a sweet tooth for life.

He also stressed that large reviews of the evidence show sweeteners do not help people lose weight.

So his advice is for everyone to shift to a less sweet diet – cutting both sugar and sweeteners – and for companies to produce foods that are less sweet, but still tasty.

One of the big outstanding research questions is how might aspartame result in cancer (if indeed it does). The WHO reports show that aspartame itself is rapidly broken down in the gut into three other substances – phenylalanine, aspartic acid and methanol.

But these are also the product of digesting a wide variety of other foods that are not linked with cancer. And the researchers concluded that aspartame is not directly making cancerous mutations in people’s DNA. Raising levels of inflammation in the body is one possibility.

Frances Hunt-Wood, secretary general of the International Sweeteners Association, said the work had “once again reaffirmed aspartame’s safety”.

She added: “Aspartame, like all low/no calorie sweeteners, when used as part of a balanced diet, provides consumers with choice to reduce sugar intake, a critical public health objective.”

There are some people who cannot safely consume aspartame. These are people with an inherited disease called phenylketonuria or PKU, who are born unable to metabolise the phenylalanine that is released as aspartame is broken down.

Follow Jameson Twitter.

- Advertisement -

Discover

Sponsor

Latest

Last resident in doomed Wishaw flats refuses to leaveon August 12, 2022 at 5:15 am

The 66-year-old says the council will need to double its offer to get him to vacate his property.The last resident of a housing estate...

Tiny data centre used to heat public swimming poolon March 14, 2023 at 2:16 am

The heat generated by the small box of powerful computers is enough to heat the pool about 60% of the time.Image source, mark@deepgreen.energyBy Zoe...

Two men dead after triple shooting in Ilfordon October 25, 2022 at 2:20 pm

One of the men, in his 20s, died at the scene and another died a short time later, police say.Two men have been killed...

The Perfect Super Bowl Defense Will Is Key

The Perfect Super Bowl Defense Will Is KeyThe question for Super Bowl 2020 is, will it be more of the same or a...

Covid: Volunteers ensure Christmas Day booster jabs pushon December 25, 2021 at 4:39 pm

Vaccinations continue over the festive period after UK Covid cases hit a record on Christmas Eve.Image source, ReutersVolunteers are working at Covid vaccination sites...