Councils in court over hotels housing asylum seekerson November 8, 2022 at 4:58 pm

- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -

Local authorities claim the accommodation schemes break planning laws and harm communities.

The four-star Novotel in the centre of IpswichImage source, Isaac Chenery/BBC

Lawyers for two councils have urged the High Court to block the Home Office’s contractors from using large hotels to house asylum seekers, claiming the schemes break planning laws and harm communities.

Ipswich Borough Council and East Riding of Yorkshire Council say the hotels in their patches are being unlawfully converted into asylum seeker hostels, and they want them stopped by court injunctions.

But lawyers for both hotels said the councils could be causing greater harm to the public by increasing pressures elsewhere and scaring off other hotels from helping the government.

The 101-bed Novotel hotel in Ipswich, Suffolk and the Hull Humber View hotel in North Ferriby have agreed to take migrants while the Home Office assesses their applications to stay in the UK.

Around 37,000 asylum seekers are in hotels across the UK, according to the Home Office.

During Tuesday’s hearing, barrister Gethin Thomas said both local authorities wanted injunctions and argued that the hotels were undergoing an unlawful change in use.

The four-star Novotel began to receive its first asylum seekers on 24 October and is no longer open to the public.

Mr Thomas told the court the Home Office had concluded two years ago that Novotel would not be appropriate for the accommodation scheme.

“One of the issues in Ipswich is the suitability of the location,” he said.

“It is the biggest hotel in Ipswich town centre. For a scheme of this scale, the planning authority want time to discuss it. The scale of support for people in the hotel may not be enough.”

Mr Thomas said the Hull Humber View hotel was also being unlawfully changed in use and that East Riding of Yorkshire Council had concerns about pressure on local services.

Questioning the councils, Mr Justice Holgate asked: “If the injunction is granted, then alternative accommodation will have to be provided. There is potential upheaval for asylum seekers. The effect of the injunction is to displace a problem, if there is a problem, elsewhere.”

“It is a problem of the Home Office’s making,” replied Mr Thomas.

The Hull Humber View hotel

In written submissions to the court, lawyers for the two hotels argued that accommodating asylum seekers did not break planning law – and the councils were in fact causing harm.

“The council seeks the court’s assistance to keep any further asylum seekers from the shelter and substance which the [Ipswich] hotel would provide,” wrote Richard Kimblin KC.

“It is tolerably clear that the council does not want those people in its town.

“The council should be very careful to confine itself to planning purposes, not generalised concerns about asylum seekers, who are going to be accommodated in any event.

“This injunction will have a chilling effect on other hotel operators who will see the mess which they may be drawn into and thus decline to assist central government.

“In turn, the supply of hotel accommodation to those who are destitute, would be diminished.”

Judgment has been reserved in the injunction applications brought by the councils. The judge gave no indication of when he would rule on the matter.

Around the BBC - Sounds
Around the BBC footer - Sounds
- Advertisement -

Discover

Sponsor

Latest

Brazil Congress: ‘Sad to think we’ve come to this point’on January 9, 2023 at 1:31 am

As Bolsonaro supporters stormed Congress, locals in Brasilia were forced to shelter in fear.As Bolsonaro supporters stormed Congress, locals in Brasilia were forced to...

Blackburn first UK football club to host Eid prayerson May 2, 2022 at 2:28 pm

The Championship side are the first UK football club to host Eid prayersBlackburn Rovers has become the first football club in the UK to...

‘Words can’t describe how happy I am’ – 16-year-old Heffernan joins AC Milanon February 1, 2022 at 11:07 am

Republic of Ireland defender Cathal Heffernan says "words can't describe" how happy he is at joining AC Milan on loan from Cork City.

Britney Spears: Singer confirms she is writing new memoiron April 5, 2022 at 1:31 am

The singer says the book will tackle painful past events she has "never been able to express openly."Image source, Getty ImagesBritney Spears has confirmed...

Sri Lanka PM tells military to do whatever necessary to restore orderon July 13, 2022 at 9:04 pm

Thousands of protesters stormed the office of Prime Minister Ranil Wickremesinghe.Image source, ReutersSri Lanka's Prime Minister Ranil Wickremesinghe has told the military to do...