Challenge over judges bailing defendantson September 26, 2022 at 5:12 am

- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -

Court delays have led judges to reject calls from prosecutors to extend the time some people are kept in jail.

Barristers protesting outside the Supreme CourtImage source, Getty Images

The director of public prosecutions is bringing a High Court challenge against judges’ refusal to detain defendants for longer ahead of trial amid record-high backlogs and legal strikes.

Delays have led judges to reject calls from prosecutors to extend the time some defendants are kept in jail.

This has led to some – even those on very serious charges – being bailed.

Monday’s test case, brought by Max Hill, head of the CPS, centres on cases in Bristol and Manchester.

Backlogs and the barristers’ strike means there is no certainty when trials will take place

In recent weeks, judges in Bristol, Leicester, Oxford, Manchester and London have rejected calls from prosecutors to extend the time that defendants are kept behind bars.

Judges have been bailing defendants facing a range of allegations, including murder and sexual assault.

Barristers in England and Wales have been on strike in a dispute with the government over legal aid funding.

Judges say the unresolved strike – or failures by ministers to act on warnings – do not give them legal powers to keep people behind bars indefinitely.

Three of those decisions made in two separate criminal cases will be challenged in the High Court case.

The Criminal Bar Association (CBA) says the criminal justice system has been run down by years of underfunding and is seeking a 25% rise in legal aid fees for representing defendants who could not otherwise afford lawyers.

The government has offered a 15% rise from the end of September. This has been rejected by the CBA, which says it would not kick in soon enough or apply to existing cases.

Justice Secretary Brandon Lewis, who was only appointed to the role a few weeks ago, met with the CBA last week and said discussions had been “constructive”.

His predecessor Dominic Raab previously refused to meet with the CBA during their action over pay.

CBA chairman Kirsty Brimelow told MPs earlier this month the group was “absolutely willing to negotiate”. She said the CBA had been willing to do so all year but “there’s been no alternative [to taking action] because we’ve had absolutely no negotiation”.

Banner Image Reading Around the BBC - Blue
Footer - Blue
- Advertisement -

Discover

Sponsor

Latest

Malaysia landslide leaves campers dead and dozens missingon December 16, 2022 at 4:04 am

Rescuers are scrambling to save scores of people at a camping site just north of the capitalThis video can not be playedTo play this...

Windrush report: Suella Braverman scraps three recommendationson January 26, 2023 at 4:41 pm

The home secretary says the changes recommended in the wake of the scandal will no longer go ahead.Image source, PA MediaThe head of the...

Ex-Post Office chair escalates compensation rowon February 21, 2024 at 5:53 pm

Henry Staunton has released a note of a call with a senior official, amid a row over Horizon payouts.Henry Staunton has released a note...

Man charged after 11-year-old girl’s disappearance in Galashielson February 8, 2023 at 1:31 am

The child went missing from Galashiels in the Borders on Sunday, but was found on Monday night.Image source, PA MediaA 53-year-old man has been...

Rangers 2-3 Benfica: Scottish side’s Champions League group hopes on knife edgeon September 20, 2022 at 8:45 pm

A controversial late goal condemns Rangers to a Champions League second-round defeat by Benfica and left their group stage hopes on a knife edge.A...