Boris Johnson: MPs reject lawyer’s claim Partygate probe unfairon September 26, 2022 at 9:46 am

- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -

MPs are examining whether Boris Johnson misled Parliament over Covid rule-breaking events in No 10.

Boris JohnsonImage source, PA Media

MPs investigating if Boris Johnson misled Parliament over Partygate have rejected claims the probe is “unfair”.

The Privileges Committee is looking into what the former PM told Parliament about Covid-rule breaking.

Lord Pannick, a lawyer hired by the government to examine the committee’s approach, called the investigation “fundamentally flawed”.

The committee said Lord Pannick had “a systemic misunderstanding of the parliamentary process”.

Mr Johnson could be suspended from Parliament or even lose his seat if the committee rules against him.

The committee is investigating whether he obstructed the Commons by telling it that pandemic rules had been followed during lockdown events in No 10 that since led to Covid fines.

Last month, the committee decided it would not have to prove Mr Johnson deliberately misled MPs to show he committed a “contempt of Parliament” by obstructing its work.

Mr Johnson could be hauled before the committee in the autumn to account for what he previously told MPs.

In his legal advice, Lord Pannick warned that “the threat of contempt proceedings for unintentional mistakes would have a seriously chilling effect” on MPs.

But the committee rejected this as “wholly misplaced and itself misleading”.

The independent crossbench peer said the committee’s approach is inconsistent with past cases where intent was taken into account and the process would be deemed “unlawful” if it was tested in a court.

He criticised the committee for taking evidence anonymously and said Mr Johnson should be told the details of the case against him.

Lord Patrick Pannick KC - lawyer

Image source, Getty Images

The committee said Lord Pannick’s opinion was “founded on a systemic misunderstanding of the parliamentary process and misplaced analogies with the criminal law”.

It rejected Lord Pannick’s call for Mr Johnson to be represented by a lawyer who would speak on his behalf and cross-examine witnesses.

In a statement the committee, said it “does not have discretion to allow counsel to speak in a hearing and conduct cross-examination, and it would require a decision of the House to permit this”.

Parliament voted to launch the inquiry in April, after a series of revelations about events held in and around Downing Street while Covid restrictions were in place.

An official investigation later concluded rules had been broken and a police inquiry led to 83 people, including Mr Johnson himself, being fined.

The prime minister has admitted that previous statements to Parliament – in which he insisted all rules had been followed – had since been proved incorrect, but he believed them to be true at the time.

He denied deliberately misleading MPs.

- Advertisement -

Discover

Sponsor

Latest

Cost of living rises at fastest pace for 30 yearson January 19, 2022 at 7:37 am

The UK's cost of living surged by 5.4% in the 12 months to December, hitting its highest level since 1992.Image source, ReutersThe cost of...

Train strikes: Are services running again and will their be more action?on November 8, 2022 at 5:00 pm

National rail strikes have been cancelled but there has still been disruption.National rail strikes have been cancelled but there has still been disruption.

World Cup 2022: Qatar ambassador comments on homosexuality ‘harmful and unacceptable’on November 8, 2022 at 7:06 pm

A Qatar World Cup ambassador calling homosexuality "damage in the mind" is "harmful and unacceptable", says Human Rights Watch.Former Qatar international Khalid Salman told...

Six Nations 2022: Scotland beat England 20-17 to retain Calcutta Cupon February 5, 2022 at 7:31 pm

Watch highlights as Scotland claim a nerve-shredding Six Nations victory over England to secure successive Calcutta Cup wins for the first time since 1984.Watch...

Jake Paul and Tommy Fury to fight in grudge matchon October 29, 2021 at 11:09 pm

Jake Paul and Tommy Fury announce they will fight in the United States on 18 December.