Rwanda asylum plan: Home Office fights bid to block flighton June 10, 2022 at 11:39 am

- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -

Lawyers tell the High Court the plan is valid and in the public interest and must go ahead.

A group of people thought to be asylum seekers brought into Dover by Border ForceImage source, PA Media

Home Office lawyers have said a plan to send asylum seekers to Rwanda must not be stopped by legal challenges – because it is in the public interest.

The government aims to discourage people crossing the English Channel to seek asylum by making it clear many cases will now be dealt with by Rwanda.

In a High Court hearing, the lawyers urged a judge to reject challenges on behalf of individual asylum seekers.

About 100 people have been told they may be on the first flight, on Tuesday.

Just before the start of the hearing, it emerged at least three people have been told they will not now be put on that flight.

The hearing centres on the Home Office’s deal with Rwanda to send some asylum seekers there to have their claims dealt with – if on their way to the UK, they had passed through a safe country where they could have alternatively claimed asylum.

In practice, the policy is targeted at English Channel crossings, with more than 10,000 so far this year.

Document telling asylum seekers they will be flown to Rwanda on 14 June 2022 and it is not an appealable decision

In papers lodged with the High Court, lawyers said: “Removal to Rwanda pursuant to the migration and economic development partnership [with Rwanda] under the inadmissibility provisions of the immigration rules pursues an important public interest.

“Removals of individuals from the UK in accordance with the MEDP are intended to deter people from making dangerous journeys to the UK to claim asylum, which are facilitated by criminal smugglers, when they have already travelled through safe third countries.

“In particular, but not exclusively, this is aimed at deterring arrivals by small boats.

“It is striking that nowhere in the claimants’ submissions [to stop the flight] is there any consideration of the impact of any public interest factors, still less any analysis or balancing of the importance of the public interest being pursued in this regard.”

The case brought against the Home Office by a coalition of campaigners has two stages.

Firstly, the claimants want to block the removal to Rwanda of specific individuals who have been told they are leaving.

Secondly, they want to challenge the lawfulness of any such transfers to Rwanda.

Raza Hussain QC, representing some of the claimants, told the court that the UN’s refugee agency was concerned about shortcomings in the Rwanda asylum system.

He said the UNHCR’s concerns included evidence that applicants for refuge could be arbitrarily denied proper access to a hearing, a lawyer and an interpreter – and could even find themselves removed to countries that torture.

The UN had not been able to properly monitor the quality of decision-making in the country despite Home Secretary Priti Patel’s claims that Rwanda was safe, he said.

Mr Hussain continued: “These are concerns that have been communicated to the UK authorities and yet the secretary of state’s position is that the UN is giving this plan a green light. That is a false claim.

“This is not the view of a very reputable NGO – it is the view of the UNHCR and it is entitled to very significant weight.”

The lawyer pointed out that the UNHCR has constitutional responsibility for oversight [of international refugee law] and institutional expertise.

“We are not on the ground in Rwanda, the secretary of state is not on the ground in Rwanda,” he said, adding: “The UNHCR is. How could you possibly implement a removal when the UNHCR has said this?”

- Advertisement -

Discover

Sponsor

Latest

Thousands of Australian nurses go on strike as Covid cases mounton February 15, 2022 at 4:08 am

The Omicron variant has led to a recent surge of cases, putting hospital systems under further strain.

Manchester City 6-0 Burnley: Erling Haaland scores hat-trick in thumping win over Vincent Kompany’s sideon March 18, 2023 at 9:24 pm

Erling Haaland scores his sixth hat-trick of the season and passes the 40-goal mark as Manchester City thrash Vincent Kompany's Burnley to reach the...

Women’s Six Nations: Emily Scarratt returns to England squadon March 7, 2022 at 3:17 pm

Emily Scarratt is set to return to the England squad for the Women's Six Nations later this month after recovering from a broken leg.

Gymnastics World Championships 2022: GB’s Jessica Gadirova makes history with all-around bronzeon November 3, 2022 at 11:15 pm

Jessica Gadirova finishes third in the women's all-around final to become the first British gymnast to win a medal in the event at the...

Senegal win Africa Cup of Nations on penaltieson February 6, 2022 at 10:44 pm

Sadio Mane nets the winning spot-kick as Senegal beat Egypt 4-2 on penalties to clinch their first-ever Africa Cup of Nations after a 0-0...