Rethink over crackdown on MPs’ second jobson March 17, 2022 at 11:02 am

- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -

Boris Johnson’s call to limit the hours MPs spend on outside work is not practical, a minister says.

House of Commons

Image source, UK PARLIAMENT

Limiting the amount of time MPs spend on second jobs would be “impractical”, the government has said.

Boris Johnson called for a review of MPs’ outside work last year after a number of high-profile controversies.

At the time, the prime minister backed proposals to place “reasonable limits” on hours spent on other jobs.

But Cabinet Office Minister Steve Barclay has now written to the Commons Standards Committee, saying the measure would not work.

He added such a policy would “not necessarily serve to address recent concerns over paid advocacy and the primary duty of MPs to serve their constituents”.

Mr Barclay also questioned whether it would be “fair” to introduce a cap on outside earnings.

Labour criticised the move and pointed the finger of blame at the prime minister, saying Mr Johnson had “repeatedly allowed his own MPs to put their own private business interests ahead of their constituents and it must be stopped”.

The issue of MPs’ second jobs came to the fore in 2021 when the then-Conservative MP Owen Paterson was found to have broken lobbying rules.

It caused chaos in government and accusations of sleaze after No 10 attempted an overhaul of the standards system, which would have stopped Mr Paterson from being suspended from the Commons. He later resigned as an MP.

The furore led to increased scrutiny of the work MPs do outside of Parliament, with a lot of focus on former Attorney General Sir Geoffrey Cox, who earned around £900,000 in 2020 through his work as a lawyer.

MPs later backed government plans to prevent them taking on certain jobs, with No 10 saying any outside role, paid or unpaid, should be “within reasonable limits” and not stop MPs fully serving their constituents.

A definition of what that meant was not given, but International Trade Secretary Anne-Marie Trevelyan suggested 15 hours a week as a reasonable limit.

However, in the letter from Mr Barclay, the government now appears to have moved away from that pledge.

‘Impractical’

The minister reiterated the government’s desire for a ban on MPs providing paid parliamentary advice, consultancy, or strategy services.

But while he acknowledged a time limit was considered “necessary” by some, he said it would be “impractical”.

In a submission to the standards committee, first reported by the Guardian, Mr Barclay wrote: “It is the government’s initial view that the imposition of fixed constraints such as time limits on the amount of time that members can spend on outside work would be impractical.

“The imposition of time limits would not necessarily serve to address recent concerns over paid advocacy and the primary duty of MPs to serve their constituents.”

When it came to a cap on earnings, Mr Barclay also had his doubts, writing that such a rule “could serve to prohibit activities which do not bring undue influence to bear on the political system”, such as writing books.

He said a long-serving MP “could inadvertently reach the ‘ceiling’ through earnings accrued over time”, and he questioned “whether it would be fair to subject that member to a standards investigation”.

He added: “To avoid this issue would require a substantive earning threshold to be set such that it would not serve to prevent MPs from taking on outside work for which they were properly remunerated in line with salaries in that sector.

“The introduction of such an arbitrary cap therefore may not have the intended effect of ensuring that members prioritise their parliamentary duties and the needs of their constituents.”

Geoffrey Cox

Image source, EPA

But Labour’s shadow leader of the House, Thangam Debbonaire, disagreed with the change in direction, accusing the PM of trying to “row back on his promises” to appease critics on his own benches.

She added: “Labour supports toughening up the standards system, with a ban on directorships and paid consultancy.

“And the House of Commons must be given the chance to debate fully and approve any measures put forward by the Standards Committee to toughen up the system.”

- Advertisement -

Discover

Sponsor

Latest

Covid-19: Hotel quarantine to come into force in UKon February 14, 2021 at 11:57 pm

Travellers will pay £1,750 to spend 10 days quarantining in government-sanctioned hotels.Travellers will pay £1,750 to spend 10 days quarantining in government-sanctioned hotels.

How many have died in school shootings since Sandy Hook?on December 13, 2022 at 12:20 am

A decade ago, a gunman opened fire at Sandy Hook Elementary in Connecticut, killing 26.A decade ago, a gunman opened fire at Sandy Hook...

The last of the Moon men: the stories of the surviving Apollo astronautson January 7, 2024 at 12:24 am

Who are the eight surviving members of humanity's greatest feat of exploration?Who are the eight surviving members of humanity's greatest feat of exploration?

Watch: The moment a whale is cut free from ropes in Norwegian Seaon July 1, 2022 at 1:26 pm

The Norwegian Coastguard came to the rescue after the whale got tangled.The Norwegian Coastguard came to the rescue after the whale got tangled.

Serena Williams unsure of Wimbledon future, but wants more Grand Slamson June 29, 2022 at 5:49 am

Serena Williams is unsure whether she will play at Wimbledon again, but says her first-round exit has motivated her.Venue: All England Club Dates: 27...