Boris Johnson’s biggest Commons rebellion – and why it matterson December 15, 2021 at 12:50 am

- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -

Two years after his greatest triumph, the PM couldn’t head off a mass Tory rejection of Covid measures.

Boris Johnson

Image source, Reuters

“The rebels are haemorrhaging.”

So said one government minister on Tuesday evening as the prime minister addressed the 1922 Committee of Conservative backbench MPs.

Boris Johnson made a last-ditch effort to win over his party in the packed meeting just an hour before the Commons voted on new Covid regulations.

He promised MPs they would be consulted on any future restrictions if they were needed. He warned his party it had “absolutely no choice but to act” and that nobody could be sure Omicron would be less severe than other variants.

Mr Johnson had also spent the day phoning potential rebels, trying to win them over to the merits of Covid certification. Meanwhile, Prof Chris Whitty briefed MPs on the rise of Omicron – with a government loyalist predicting this would win some over.

Leading figures in government seemed to think their argument was working. One senior cabinet minister said on Tuesday evening that the PM’s efforts had gone down well.

Mr Johnson himself declared to journalists after the 1922 Committee that he had done his best to persuade his party.

It wasn’t enough. Far from it.

The rebellion on Covid passes was far bigger than many had predicted and by some distance the biggest of Mr Johnson’s premiership.

It’s all the more significant because of the prime minister’s efforts to limit the damage.

What will worry Downing Street is that the vote brought different wings of the Conservative Party together in opposition to the government’s plans.

There was the Covid Recovery Group of backbenchers, who had long been sceptical of restrictions and had consistently voted against the government.

But there were also centrists like Damian Green – who told BBC Radio 4’s World at One that the plans for Covid certification wouldn’t work, saying: “It’s a gesture. It’s doing something for the sake of doing something.”

Anti-Covid pass placard

Image source, EPA

Then there were the likes of the Scottish Conservatives, who do not believe Covid passports worked in Scotland.

They didn’t take part in the Commons vote because the measures only applied to England – but they made their opposition abundantly clear.

Aberdeenshire MP Andrew Bowie told me: “We need to stop lurching from a something must be done position. Vaccine passports do not work.”

As well as the 99 confirmed Covid pass rebels, there were many more who sat on their hands.

One former minister, a Johnson loyalist while in government, said he had made plans to avoid having to back Covid passports.

We don’t know for certain how many took a similar position, but it takes the number refusing to back Mr Johnson over the 100 mark.

A majority of MPs did ultimately back Covid certification and the measures will still be brought in in England.

But a prime minister with a majority of 80 was forced to rely on opposition votes to get his plans through. That raises two big questions.

The first: Is Mr Johnson’s authority waning?

Number 10 has undoubtedly been battered and bruised by the controversies of the past fortnight.

But in the past, Mr Johnson has been able to persuade and cajole his MPs into backing him – often when they didn’t want to. This time, it just didn’t work.

Secondly, will Mr Johnson now have to think twice about introducing more restrictions if they are needed?

This point is more complicated because there are some MPs who didn’t like Covid certification – but do back other measures to stop the spread of Omicron and may vote for more in future.

But one leading and long-standing Covid rebel called this vote a shot across Downing Street’s bow – a warning of what might be to come if the government did opt for stricter restrictions in the coming weeks.

Two years ago, Mr Johnson won a general election which gave him the biggest Conservative majority since Margaret Thatcher.

After months of Brexit battles in Parliament, the assumption was December 2019 marked the end of mass Tory rebellions.

Tuesday’s vote proved that wasn’t the case.

- Advertisement -

Discover

Sponsor

Latest

Hull City 0-2 Luton Town: Hatters consign managerless hosts to home defeaton September 30, 2022 at 9:02 pm

Luton Town inflict a sixth Championship defeat of the season on Hull City, who sacked manager Shota Arveladze just hours before kick-off.Luton Town inflict...

Online dating: ‘In 2021 everyone is a kind-of catfish’on April 20, 2021 at 12:03 am

The hit US reality show is getting its own UK version - hosted by Julie Adenuga and Oobah Butler.image copyrightMTVIt was back in 2010...

£400 energy payment: Fears landlords to keep renters’ rebateon August 3, 2022 at 9:24 am

Where a tenant's bills are included in their rent the energy rebate will be paid to their landlord.Image source, Getty ImagesTenants whose bills are...

The Papers: Royal Mail ‘cyberattack’ and mortgage default warningon January 12, 2023 at 1:07 am

Thursday's papers lead with fears of a surge in cyber crime and the impact of the cost of living crisis.Thursday's papers lead with fears...

Jack Dorsey: What’s next for Twitter’s co-founder?on November 30, 2021 at 3:48 am

The last time the tech visionary left Twitter, he set up another company now worth $100bn.